Originally Posted by Ranchu Lover

No need to fight or controvercy over this subject. The result of the goldfish will determine which is the better method. If you feel that GW is better, then use it. If you think that CW is better, then use it. Still got many many more competition coming and we can see which is better. Heard that there is a competition coming in November somewhere near Clementi MRT area. Better start getting all your fish ready. 5 more months to go.


I am not an expert, just another hobbyist like all of you. Goldfish will forever be a hobby to me and will never be my life. There are many many better things to do in life other than keeping goldfish.

You already know what I believe in. I will show you guys some of my fish at a later date for you to see how they have developed in CW.

Like this better don't keep goldfish. See GW enough liao.

For those who are interested to know my keeping method, you are very wellcome to my home (by appointment only because of my very busy schedule).

Originally Posted by IKI

For me I prefer Gw...... better growth n health....... back home from work also tired liao, never bother to see them also........ so only weekend when doing WC , den can see them..........heee:D

Originally Posted by IKI

Green water or clear water better??? I know its subjective, but i just wanna hear bros here say, whats ur opinion??? Personally I feel that green water is still the better......in terms of growth n health.....what do bros here think???

Originally Posted by Sotong King

Firstly, goldfish kept in gw are more healthy then why need to see them everyday.:) Only those who keep them in cw need to see - actually check them everyday because there is always problem.:o

Secondly, rarely do we see people using gw post of problem in this forum.:) But look through all the past threads, all those who posted of problems are the ones who keep goldfish in cw.:rolleyes:

Originally Posted by Runzhu

How can you said like that, some ppl have problem so switched to CW. And don forget many having problem because they are newbies.

Originally Posted by Sotong King

Hi, you mean gw got no newbie?:eek:

Originally Posted by Ranchu Lover

Do my goldfish look lousy and sick? Don't forget that my $2/- pearlscale has been raised in CW from very young. I wonder what is happening to all those pearlscales that are raised in GW. I am sure that many many people are raising their pearlscales in GW as well. What happened to them?